Related
Star Wars : The ascension of Skywalkerwould have been much better had Rey fallen to the grim side . The trailer forStar Wars : The lift of Skywalkeroffered a thrilling coup d’oeil of a moody side version of Rey , teeth debar , an strange switchblade knife lightsaber in her handwriting . Unfortunately , Star Wars : The Rise of Skywalkerwasted Dark Rey , as demonstrate by construct nontextual matter that experimented with the idea .
This , by nature , has led to intense speculation about just howStar warfare : The Rise of Skywalkercould have originate the estimation . The core group problem , of course , is that there ’s not really any path to overwork it to its full potential and yet end the story in the space of a single film ; it ’s too challenging an idea , with far too much potential , and skillful filmwriters would have wanted the room to play with it forward of a redemption turn ( this is stillStar Wars , after all ) . The unfortunate truth is that , had Lucasfilm decided to turn tail with Dark Rey , the turn would have been well determine up in the previous film .
Related : Casting A Star Wars : A New Hope Reboot
AssumingRey turned to the dark sideinStar Wars : The Last Jedi , things would of course have played out very otherwise ; Lucasfilm would have made completely unlike originative choices hold out forward . Still , for the sake of imagining this event , it ’s interesting to picture a scenario where Rey fall to the black side but everything else stick the same . Here ’s how things could have played out .
Why Rey Would Have Turned To The Dark Side In Star Wars: The Last Jedi
Star Wars : The Last Jediwas essentially Rey ’s moment of big temptation . Although Luke Skywalker believed his former student Kylo Ren was beyond redemption , Rey take a firm stand that was not the case . Kylo Ren , for his part , was evenly sure-footed he had sensed growing wickedness within Rey , and he hoped to draw her towards the sullen side of the Force . Neither knew they were part of alegendary Force Dyad , a phenomenon that appear to involve both light and moody , and so both were right . InStar warfare : The Last Jedi , neither heeded the call of the other , and the two lesion up on opposing side . But it ’s easy to suppose a scenario where things play out other than , and Rey took Kylo Ren ’s hand , sweep up her own inner darkness .
Luke Skywalker & Leia Would Have Saved The Resistance
This was Luke Skywalker ’s greatest fear , and it could well have become a reality . The plot would have been a dark inversion ofThe Empire Strikes Back , with Rey failing to accompany in Luke ’s footstep by reject the dark side . With Rey gone , it would have fallen to the heroes of the past to find a way to salve the outlive Resistance members fromthe First Order . Presumably Luke would have get by to distract both Rey and Kylo Ren , and in this timeline it would have been Leia who used the Force to empty the detritus at the back of the old Rebel base on Crait . Luke ’s intervention would likely have leave behind him die , as in the primary timeline , while Leia ’s action at law would have critically weakened her . The baton would have been well and truly passed on to a newfangled contemporaries of Resistance leader , with Poe and Finn forced to step up .
What Would Have Happened Between The Last Jedi & The Rise Of Skywalker?
This would have been a far darker timeline . Rey and Kylo Ren would have stood joined as Supreme Leaders of the First Order . It ’s sensible to assume they would have realizedthey were a Force Dyad(Kylo Ren figured it out before Palpatine inStar Wars : The advance of Skywalker , after all ) . Tapping into the power of the Dyad , they ’d have become more powerful than ever before ; tie beam - ins have suggested Rey and Kylo Ren barely began to scratch the surface of the Dyad ’s potential . Crucially , though , each would have still feel the pull of the light side of the Force .
Related : Star Wars Hints At Rey & Kylo ’s Greatest Force Power ( The Sequels Ignored )
Meanwhile , the Resistance would have reorganized under the leaders of Finn and Poe . In this timeline , Poe pass barely any time with Rey , and he ’d therefore have conclude she was gone . Finn , however , would have retain his unshakable religion in Rey . It ’s interesting to imagine a scenario where Finn ’s Force - predisposition was sensed by Luke and Leia , and he was the one who expend a yr breeding as a Jedi in Rey ’s position . Finn could have finally had a Jedi arc , fulfilling the promise of poster forStar war : The Force Awakens , which read him wielding a lightsaber .
The Emperor’s Rise Of Skywalker Return Would Have Been Very Different
Assuming that the incite incident ofStar Wars : The Rise of Skywalker- Palpatine ’s unexpected rejoinder on the ancient Sith redoubt of Exegol , staring with a fleet of Death Star Destroyers - still served as the A - plot , the Emperor would have found himself operating in a far more dangerous context . This is because Rey and Kylo Ren would have been unite against him . No doubt Rey would have been shaken to acquire she was a Palpatine , but this revelation would n’t have been as someone - destroy as in the main timeline , because she was already attempting to embrace the dark side .
The Resistance would have revere an coalition between Palpatine and Supreme LeadersRey and Kylo Ren , and they ’d have presumably begun the same quest to discover Exegol . The most interesting story would have been one in which the still - sapless Leia and Finn refused to give up on redeem the First Order ’s two drawing card , even as Poe insisted a military strategy was the only way forward . This translation ofStar war : The Rise of Skywalkerwould probably have play out very otherwise , with Finn attain out to Rey and a dying Leia to Kylo Ren . In this narration , Rey and Kylo Ren would essentially have become the fulcrum on which the whole Galax urceolata tilted ; their selection of dark had instituted a period of time of regal ruler , and their eventual redemption would have turned the extragalactic nebula towards the light again . There ’s a mother wit in which both would have body forth the bequest ofthe prefer One , because their choice would have determined the entire galaxy ’s balance .
Redemption lies at the heart ofStar Wars , so this would surely have been the fitting outcome . In this retelling ofStar Wars : The Rise of Skywalker , it would be Rey and Kylo Ren ( now Ben Solo once again ) who stood unify against Palpatine in the end . No doubt they would have pay a heavy damage , for there has always been a toll to salvation inStar Wars , but hopefully both would have survived . This option termination would have seen the First Order ’s Supreme Leaders step down , having defeated Palpatine and eliminate the dismal side once and for all . It would then open up stories in which the two seek to re - establish the Jedi Order alongside Finn , even as they hop to regain the beetleweed ’s cartel . That would have been a far more challenging foundation for post - sequel trilogy report .
