Related
Would Disney’sStar Warsmovies have fared better - and suffered less controversy - if both spinoffs had released before the sequel trilogy even begin ? TheStar Warsfranchise finds itself in alien district at present . rearing success withThe Mandalorianand a wave of Kenobi - themed excitement proveLucasfilm ’s Disney+ experimentrepresents a force out win for all involved . On the big screenland , however , a run of factious or middling motion picture culminated in a lackluster response toStar Wars : The Rise of Skywalker . A lukewarmRogue Squadronis now the onlyStar Warsfilm with a ( semi ) definite tone ending day of the month , while conductor for other task are drop quicker than the main mould ofRogue One .
Related : Lando Can Fix Star Wars ' Nostalgia Problem & Show Its Post - TROS Future
In the end , we gotStar Wars : The Force Awakens(2015),Rogue One(2016),Star war : The Last Jedi(2017),Solo(2018 ) , andStar Wars : The Rise of Skywalker(2019 ) . Would Disney’sStar Warsmovies have do well if that chronology instead read : Rogue One , Solo , Star Wars : The Force Awakens , Star war : The Last Jedi , andStar state of war : The wage increase of Skywalker ?
Rogue One Captured Force Awakens' Original Trilogy Feel Without A Retread
remaining as it may seem now the humans is eagerly anticipatingHayden Christensen ’s return as Darth Vader , George Lucas’Star Warsprequel trilogy was not especially well - loved in the early 2010s . With " meesa Jar Jar Binks " and Anakin ’s flaxen membership still ring fresh in the ear , the general consensus as Lucasfilm set about break theStar Warssequel trilogy was to retake the original movies ' magic . J.J. Abrams’Star Wars : The Force Awakensis , for that very grounds , an unapologetic dearest letter to the past . Han Solo , Chewbacca and Leia restitution , the Rebellion vs. Empire premise is reestablished under dissimilar figure , and the whole tone shifts acutely away from trade disputes and senate meetings . The reverence with which Rey and her fellow starter speak of the old days even mirror how fans talked about the original trilogy .
Despite fulfilling its brief to " recapture erstwhile illusion , " that nostalgic compulsion becameStar war : The Force Awakens ' heavy defect . Many limited review ( and later George Lucas himself ) pointed out how the overall structure and premise of Abrams’Star Warsdebut copiedA New Hopealmost to the letter of the alphabet . A force out - sensitive hero desperate to leave their tyrannical desert satellite … a elephantine , existence - killing space station destruct by plucky freedom fighter aircraft … the ego - forfeit of a veteran warrior from legend … EvenStar Odysseymight’ve had a quiet parole withStar Wars : The Force Awakensabout copying George Lucas ' homework a little more subtly .
As the firstStar Warsmovie in a decade , Abrams ' opener set a backwards - looking precedent for Disney ’s full sequel era . Yet the " feel " ofStar Wars ' original trilogy could ’ve been recreatedwithouta sweeping retread ofLuke Skywalker ’s 1977 debut- andRogue Oneproves it . do immediately beforeA New Hope , Gareth Edwards’Rogue Oneretains all the legitimacy and intent of classicStar Wars , but in the wholly reinvigorated pretext of a war heroic poem . Strong protagonists , humorous droids , and monolithic battles are all present , butRogue Onenevertheless provide a totally new experience for theStar Warsfaithful . Had the prequel spinoff released in 2015 instead ofStar Wars : The Force Awakens , Lucasfilm would ’ve succeeded in their deputation to raise fond memory of its original trilogy … but averted the booby trap of becoming a tribute routine .
Related : Walter Elias Disney Needs To decently mend Its LGBTQ+ Mistakes In All Franchises
Star Wars' Spinoffs Were Impacted By Sequel Reception
It ’s no secret thatRogue Oneendured extensive reshoots late in production , with Tony Gilroy make over intact chunk of movie . The full extent ofRogue One ’s changes and Disney ’s reasons for apply them stay a issue of disputation , with conflict statements from various parties . We can , however , remainder assure that theRogue Onereshootswere far in overindulgence of distinctive post - production pickups most blockbusters undergo .
The overriding reason forRogue One ’s reshapingappearsto be narrative confusion triggered by too many cooks in the originative process , but a report from mid-2016 ( originally byDeadline ) claimed Disney executives were liken Gareth Edwards ' spinoff unfavourably toStar Wars : The Force Awakens , which had by then attained Brobdingnagian critical and commercial succeeder . The full truth of those news report only " Disney executives " know for indisputable , but the idea thatStar Wars : The Force Awakens ' success might ’ve impactedRogue Oneis certainly a plausible one .
Rogue Oneultimately win in spite of its jumpy output , and a last act bloodbath means you ca n’t precisely accuse Disney of adulterate the story ’s coloured feel … but thenSolohappened . equate to the behind - the - scenes bother Han ’s spinoff suffered , Rogue Onewas a saunter through the champaign of Naboo . Again , the factors that build towardLucasfilm lease Ron Howard in place of Phil Lord & Christopher Millerwere far from straightforward , with practical and creative element both in play . report have , however , maintained how Lord & Miller defend a wild going from theStar Warstemplate , while their employers wanted something more in - keeping with the established flair - the kind utilized byStar Wars : The Force Awakens .
Even post - release , Solofound itself affected by theStar Warssequel trilogy . Han Solo ’s soloSolomovie had the misfortune of arriving amidst a hugely partisanStar Wars : The Last Jedidebate , and premiering to such a mussy landscape painting very likely influenced interview perception of the spinoff . HadRogue OneandSolopreceded theStar Warssequel trilogy , both could ’ve develop without the looming specter ofStar Wars : The Force Awakenspossibly shake the creative process , and both could ’ve released to audiences unbiased by the winner and failures ofDisney ’s sequel trilogy .
Related : Anakin ’s New Star Wars Return Shows How bad The Sequels fail Him
Starting With Spin-Offs Gives Disney Time To Plan Star Wars' Sequel Trilogy
A full lack of coherence is perhaps the override critique guide toward Disney’sStar Warssequel trilogy . Star state of war : The Force Awakensposed a whole gang of riveting questions . Where did Supreme Leader Snoke come from ? Who are Rey ’s parent ? Why did Luke Skywalker vanish ? J.J. Abrams also set out a roster of riveting characters , from Rey as a resolute and talented Jedi padawan , to Finn as an ex - Stormtrooper seek direction . Star Wars : The Last JediandStar Wars : The Rise of Skywalkerthen struggled to answer those arcs , hack bits , transfer others , and openly contradicting the pic before . Star Wars ' continuation trilogywould’ve benefited enormously from a clean-cut three - movie plan that mapped out every major pulsation in advance .
WithStar Wars : The Force Awakenspremiering a mere 3 years after Disney ’s acquisition of Lucasfilm was announced , there simply was n’t time to contrive so far forward - but that ’s where releasing theStar Warsspinoffs first could ’ve test strategically shrewd . Rogue OneandSoloare standalone tale drawing upon exist lineament and outcome , demanding much less provision and foresight than theStar Warssequel trilogy . Both spinoffs could ’ve been make grow in time for Lucasfilm ’s 2015 and 2016 spill slot , and that affords J.J. Abrams an superfluous two years to plot out a full trilogy . By the timeStar Wars : The Force Awakensthen premieres in 2017 , a tenacious vision for the subsequent two continuation is already in place .
patently , Disney think set in motion itsStar Wars ' sequel trilogywas the priority , and from a selling standpoint , it ’s well-off to see why " Episode VII " hold more ingathering than " Remember those Death Star plan ? Here ’s everyone who died stealing them . " By pursuing both avenues side - by - side , however , Star Warsshacked its spinoffs with an unnecessary sequel trilogy burden , and burdened its continuation trilogy with the shackles of a rushed released schedule .
More : Star Wars : Why Rey Was Never Really A Palpatine
