Related
DespiteStar war : The Rise of Skywalker ’s attempt at retconning Rey ’s derivation , Rey “ no one ” was still far better than Rey Palpatine . The main character in theStar Warssequels , Rey was introduced as one ofStar state of war : The Force Awakens ’ many mystery boxes . The 2d vexer forThe Force Awakenshinted at some sorting of Skywalker lineage , as it used Luke’s“the Force is strong in my family”line fromReturn of the Jedi . However , while Kylo Ren was revealed to be a Skywalker boy of Leia and Han Solo , Rey ’s parent remain a secret – one that the sequel trilogy did n’t recognise how to properly resolve .
Some ofStar Wars ’ most important and sinewy Jedi do not necessarily descend from a kin of solid Force - sensitives . In fact , most of the Jedi introduce intheStar Warsprequelsor repair serial likeThe Clone WarsandStar Wars Rebelsdidn’t hail from blood line of relevance . Still , The Force Awakenswas marketed as a legacy sequel to the original trilogy , which had two major Skywalker family twists . Star Warswould never be able to replicateThe Empire Strikes Back ’s Darth Vader reveal , yetThe Force Awakensset up the idea that Rey could be the daughter of a very crucial character .
pertain : Palpatine Never Truly Controlled The Force - Even In The Dark Times
Why The Star Wars Sequel Trilogy’s Rey “No One” Twist Worked
From the momentThe Force Awakenshit theaters to the firstStar Wars : The Last Jediscreenings , the Brobdingnagian majority of theStar Warssequels - related theory were regarding Rey ’s parents . From Rey Solo to Rey Skywalker , allRey parentage theorieswere plausible given whatThe Force Awakens ' mystery box had specify up , yet none were something that Rey ’s story really involve for . Maz Kanata telegraphed that what mattered most to Rey was not her past , but rather her time to come – Luke Skywalker . Still , there was an prospect for a major Rey divulge inThe Last Jedi , something that the moving-picture show used to create an even more unexpected twist .
The Last Jedisimply give away that Rey was a"nobody " – perhaps the most shocking and least wait outcome for the Rey lineage debate . It was a utter twist in the fiber ’s story , a despairing heroine who had been abandon by her likely dad parent on Jakku . ThedivisiveThe Last Jediwas about the meaning of words like “ submarine ” and “ legend , ” and the melodic theme was that Rey did not need to come up from a powerful family to be the hero . The Last Jediwas also about letting the past times die , as Kylo Ren put it – the Jedi , the Sith , Snoke – and Rey was the consummate example of that .
As a “ no one , ” Rey had the potential to be the starting time of a new , excitingStar Warsstory that had nothing to do with Luke , Leia , or any other establishedStar Warscharacter . In follow that access , the sequel films could have been more than just tributes to the legacy of the original trilogy . TheRey “ nobody ” twistnever contradicted anything inThe Force Awakens , and rather add up even more meaning to Rey ’s journey . Rey had been looking for something that would never bring back , which was holding back her potential as a Jedi during her lonely years on Jakku .
Palpatine’s Reveal Undermined Rey’s “No One” Message
More than a shocking twist created just to subvert arithmetic mean , the Rey “ no one ” discover encapsulatedThe Last Jedi ’s perfect message – anyone could be the hero of their own floor . Luke Skywalker was a caption , the great Jedi Master the galaxy had seen in decades years , yet he was also flawed . Rey ’s legacy did n’t demand to be definedbyLuke or Leia , which would will her free to bulge her own story . That was an interesting parallel with Kylo Ren , who did come from the mighty Skywalker phratry and require to get by that legacy , while also seeking to be like Darth Vader .
relate : What If Rey turn To The Dark Side ? rising slope Of Skywalker pay off Much Better !
By revealing that Rey was really Palpatine ’s granddaughter all along , Star Wars : The Rise of SkywalkerunderminedThe Last Jedi ’s primary content . ThoughStar Warsretcons have always exist and will continue to , the Rey Palpatine bring out snub everythingThe Last Jedihad constitute about Rey with a story that seemed more focused on “ fixing ” the previous film ’s divisive here and now , rather than telling its own . Rey Palpatine added near nothing to the character , and it all countermine the idea that Rey had become powerful in her own rightfield . To add to the confusion , not onlywas Rey a Palpatine , but she and Kylo Ren attained much of their powerfulness by being a pair in the Force .
There are no meaningful interaction between Rey and Palpatine inThe boost of Skywalker , and the reveal has no effect on any other characters . It ’s hard to believe that Kylo Ren , who had such a recondite connection with Rey , was completely wrong about her lineage inThe Last Jedi . With the retcon , Rey and Ben Solo were no longer the protagonists of their own story – Palpatine was . Even hard to accept is that Luke , who inThe Last Jedidiscussed affair like legacy so much , would hide the accuracy about Rey being a Palpatine for so long . Those problems played against Rey ’s legacy , with the “ Rey Skywalker ” line pass water it all even worse .
Rey Palpatine Highlights The Sequel Trilogy’s Biggest Problem
The Rey Palpatine retcon showcases the sequel trilogy ’s crowing problem : the deficiency of centering . Rey as Palpatine ’s granddaughterwould not have been a job had that been the plan from the beginning . Instead , The Rise of Skywalkercame across as a massiveThe Last Jediretcon , even if that is not what the motion picture intended . The original trilogy was n’t planned to the letter itself , but giving Rey two altogether different origin stories evidence a clear lack of commitment from the sequels ' filmmakers . The Last Jedi ’s Rey “ no one ” reveal felt very classic , meaning that any other Rey crook would necessarily sound like a hook and tack . As a result , The cost increase of Skywalkerwas not a satisfying conclusion to the trilogy .
Even without an overarching plan for the sequel trilogy , the Rey Palpatine retcon was avertible . The Rise of Skywalkercould have stood by the determination made inThe Last Jediand spread out on them , irrespective of whether or notPalpatine would somehow return . In fact , The Rise of Skywalkerhad the chance to say a very standardised floor without Rey being a Palpatine . Darth Sidious could still be look for a new vessel while manipulating the First Order and Kylo Ren , all without underminingThe Last Jedi ’s story . Even the“Rey Skywalker”line might have mold better had Rey remained a nobody .
come to : New Rey Parentage Reveal Makes Rise Of Skywalker ’s Palpatine Twist Worse
From Palpatine being the villain all along in a confusing twist that made Snoke even more of a question mark to Rey ’s lineage , Star Wars : The Rise of Skywalkerstruggled with the continuation ’ overall lack of focusing . Still , among all the new reveals andThe Last Jediretcons , Rey as a Palpatine is the one that injure the trilogy the most . AStar Warssequel trilogyrewatch with the Rey Palpatine kink in mind makesThe Last Jediredundant , almost as if the game - changing middle chapter did n’t really matter . The Rey Palpatine eddy would be as ifReturn of the Jedirevealed that Darth Vader was not really Luke ’s father .
More : What Would Palpatine Have Done If He ’d Discovered Luke Before Vader Did ?
