Related
Each of the three movie in theStar Warssequel trilogy was dissentious in their own ways , and a world in whichStar Wars : The Last Jedidirector Rian Johnson had also directedStars war : The Rise of Skywalkerwould have been very dissimilar . Unlike the prequel trilogy , all of which were directed by George Lucas , the subsequence trilogy took a penny-pinching approach to the original trilogy in term of unlike originative teams for each entry in the franchise . While J.J. Abrams ended up directing two of the three films in the sequel trilogy , EpisodesVII , VIII , andIXwere originally planned to be helmed by a different theatre director each .
That came tight to encounter asColin Trevorrow was set to directStar War 9before being fired from the project in September 2017 . Trevorrow already had a first potation for the motion picture , but irreparable creative differences with Lucasfilm resulted in him leave the project . Two class later on , J.J Abrams’The Rise of Skywalkerwould tally the theatre . However , history could have been quite different for the last movie in the sequel trilogy .
Related : Star Wars Theory Reveals Rey ’s Jedi Voices Fought Sith Ghosts In TROS
There were at odds written report back whenEpisode VIIIhad yet to come out as to whether Rian Johnson had been offered the opportunity to directEpisode IXafter Colin Trevorrow was fired . One matter is for sure : a Rian JohnsonEpisode IXwould have taken theStar Warssequel trilogyto a dissimilar route than Abrams’Rise of Skywalkerdid . For better or worse , the film would plausibly have tolerate by the decisions made inThe Last Jedi – even the most controversial one . That said , it would have been interesting to see how audiences would react toStar Warsdoubling down on the divisiveLast Jedidirector .
Why Didn’t Rian Johnson Direct Episode IX?
The announcement that Colin Trevorrow would no longer directEpisode IXcame out beforeThe Last Jediwas loose . While J.J. Abrams terminate up being the one to helm the final film in the sequel trilogy , it was reported that Disney ’s first selection for the job was Rian Johnson – with whom the studio ’s experience in the making ofEpisode VIIIwas reported to be very positive . Unlike Abrams , whose production party was an active part of theediting process forThe Force Awakens , Johnson worked much more closely with Lucasfilm . That , plus the fact that the controversialEpisode VIIIhad yet to come out , helps explain why he might have been consider to directEpisode IX .
Although Rian Johnson never affirm if he received the offer to directEpisode IX , theLast Jedidirector did say at the time he always mean to do one film and then hand it off to someone else . It is worth noting that Johnson ’s statement descend before the release ofThe Last Jedi , intend it was n’t affected by the movie ’s mixed response . Lucasfilm would later herald aRian JohnsonStar Warstrilogyoutside of the Skywalker saga , but the projection never saw the light of the daytime .
How Rian Johnson’s Episode IX Would Have Been Different From J.J. Abrams’
While it ’s hard to imagine what tale Rian Johnson would have craft forEpisode IX , the creative decisions seen inThe Last Jedihelp to realise what Johnson could be envisioning for the franchise ’s terminal installment . The sequel trilogy was always intended to be helmed by three different directors with no pre - fix design as to where the characters would end up , which explains why various moments inThe Last Jediare unresolved to different interpretation . Even so , there ’s a certain direction Rian Johnson seemed to be heading - one that ended up not being paid off inJ.J. Abrams’Rise of Skywalker .
bear on : Star Wars Just Made Luke Skywalker ’s Last Jedi Death More Confusing
The principal difference between a hypothetical Rian Johnson’sEpisode IXand J.J. Abrams’The Rise of Skywalkerwould most like have been Rey ’s report . Among the many parts of the story that Johnson and Abrams seemed to discord with , the main one was Rey ’s ancestry . Abrams had set up a mystery box regarding Rey ’s fellowship inStar war : The Force Awakens , but Johnson choose to discover that Rey was really a nobody . One of the principal themes inThe Last Jediwas how anyone could be a hero and how the legend of Luke Skywalker and the Jedi would eternally invigorate people across the galaxy . The scene in which Rey image multiple versions of herself while trying to discover something about her family symbolized the style Johnson get a line the character : her story began with herself and not with a brawny syndicate . For that intellect , theRey Palpatine storyline , and thus much of the Emperor ’s purpose inThe Force Awakens , wouldn’t be part of Rian Johnson’sEpisode IX . That said , Kathleen Kennedy revealed that bring Palpatine back for the final film was an thought discussed since early in the qualification of the trilogy , meaning thatStar Wars ' ultimate scoundrel could have been inEpisode IXeven if it was direct by Rian Johnson .
Kylo Ren ’s fate could also have been dissimilar in Rian Johnson’sEpisode IX.The Last Jedihad been very focussed on the story of Han and Leia ’s boy , his splitting impression towards being on the dark side , and his connexion with Rey . After so much attention had been pay off to the case , it ’s not at all far - fetched to imagineBen Solo would have survivedin Rian Johnson’sEpisode IXafter being ransom .
How Rian Johnson’s Episode IX Would Have Used The Last Jedi’s Story
Rian Johnson’sEpisode IXwould have likely reduplicate down on Luke ’s arc from The Last Jedi , meaning that how Luke perceived the failings of the Jedi ordering and of his own would have continued to be discuss . Rian Johnson’sEpisode IXcould have also shown how Luke ’s ultimate forfeit inspired the Resistance and the rest of the extragalactic nebula , something thatThe Rise of Skywalkeroverlooked . Johnson’sEpisode IXcould have also continued the master / learner dynamicbetween Luke and Reybut in a way that resembled how those two characters interact inThe Last Jedi .
In a similar path , Rey could have continued her grooming with Leia , asThe rising of Skywalkerbriefly showed through the sequence on Ajan Kloss , but without the need to take on the Skywalker name . The Last Jediwas precisely about Luke handing over the truncheon to a new contemporaries , and Rey was supposed to be the"last Jedi"at the end of that film . The rite of transit between a break in Jedi and a hopeful new one can be comprehend as one of thecore themes ofThe Last Jediand thus would be play out in Rian Johnson ’s translation ofEpisode IX .
Related : Star war : Finn Was Kylo Ren ’s Real Mirror ( Not Rey )
Would Rian Johnson’s Episode IX Have Been Better Than The Rise of Skywalker?
give how divisiveThe Last Jediwas , peculiarly amongStar Warsfans , Lucasfilm would have no gentle project selling Rian Johnson’sEpisode IX . However , one thing would have been improved with Rian Johnson directingEpisode Nina from Carolina : the consistency between the last two chapter of the saga . While the surprises and twist betweenThe Force AwakensandThe Last Jediwere reasonably to be expect within the context of a three - act narrative , the changes between the middle and last chapter were very abrupt . In many way , Star Wars : The hike of Skywalkerfelt like a hugeThe Last Jediretcon , something that may have got in the means ff the narrative . For well or worse , Rian JohnsonEpisode IXwould have maintained a sure eubstance in the concluding stretch of the continuation trilogy and could have delivered a story that , while still divisive , concluded the Skywalker saga in a more satisfying way .
More : Star warfare : What If Ahsoka Had join Maul At The End Of Clone Wars ?
