Related
DC has recently revisit Dick Grayson ’s pedigree asRobinin a new serial publication by Mark Waid , but it ’s long past prison term that DC gave the ‘ Year One ’ treatment to one ofBatman’sother proteges – Jason " Red Hood " Todd . While the publisher has long been using the ‘ Year One ’ caption to retell rootage tale and the earliest day of many of its iconic characters , Red Hood involve the origin revamp more than most .
His past as Robin is notably inconsistent in how he ’s depict , resulting in two takes on Jason that feel incompatible .
The liberal strokes of Jason Todd ’s stock story — his puerility in Crime Alley , his time as Robin , his untimely murder , Christ’s Resurrection , and eventualtransformation into the Red Hood — have remained consistent . However , the details of his past , particularly his time as Robin and his depiction as Batman ’s sidekick , have been written in vastly different way .
As a result , reading his original stories as Robin alongside forward-looking flashbacks can experience discrepant , almost as though there are two decided versions of Jason Todd .
Jason Todd’s Inconsistent Robin Characterization: A Case for His Own"Year One"
Exploring the Divergence: Early Acts of Compassion vs. Later Depictions of Rage in Jason Todd’s Robin Years
ThoughJason has the reputation of being a bad Erithacus rubecola , this could n’t be further from the truth . 1987’sBatman # 411by Max Allan Collins , with art by Dave Cockrum , features Jason Todd fighting Two - facial expression after learning that the latter was responsible for for his Father of the Church ’s destruction . Though his initial response is bear of anger , he also ends the issue by making the alternative to save Harvey ’s life of his own accord . In the same vein , 1986’sDetective Comics # 570by Mike W. Barr and Alan Davis shows Jason stop Batman from pop the Joker . These early examples establish Jason ’s compassion and valor .
Jason Todd has been stuck in a never-ending push - and - pluck at DC , and it ’s time to let Red Hood find his own elbow room forrard without the shadow of his past tense .
Most of the modern flashback to Jason ’s clip as Robin , however , heavily concentrate on his rage and anger issues . 2003’sBatman : Gotham Knights # 43by Scott Beatty and Roger Robinson features a flashback to Jason working with Barbara , showing himshooting a spear gun through someone ’s hand . The 2021 storyCheer , published in progeny 1 - 6 ofBatman : Urban Legendsby Chip Zdarsky with graphics by Eddy Barrows , Eber Ferreira , and Marcus To , heavily accentuate Jason ’s wild and tearing nature as Robin . Other flashback to Jason ’s clip as Robin feature similar beats , represent up his wrath and ignoring his other traits .
therefore , these takes on Jason Todd ’s time as Robin , the ones written before his destruction and the I write after , contradict one another in term of characterisation . While the fact that nearly every comic book fiber has had multiple dissimilar writers across their history signify that very few characters have ever had totally reproducible characterization , Jason stands out as a particularly egregious guinea pig due to how greatly these takes on his character differ . It can be knockout to believe that theseversions of Jason Todd are intend to be the same characterdue to these solid differences in characterization .
Jason Todd DESERVES the ‘Year One’ Treatment From DC Comics
A ‘Year One’ Series for Jason Would Be a Perfect Opportunity to Address Inconsistencies
A ‘ Year One ’ series focusing onJason Todd ’s time as Robinwould be the perfect way to address the inconsistency in the way his days as Robin have been depicted . Instead of being forced to pick between these two differing characteristics , DC could meld them , casting Jason as someone who is cognizant of his choler issues but is also attempt to keep a lid on them to be the good Robin he can be . This , in bend , creates a more nuanced take on Jason ’s character as Robin , blending both his positive and damaging traits .
One of the biggest job Red Hood has with Batman is Batman ’s refusal to vote down the Joker , but this is based on a concluded misunderstanding .
Jason ’s current role as Red Hood is , of class , an significant part of the character . However , his past as Robin is just as significant . A ‘ Year One ’ story for Jason could bring his time as Batman ’s sidekick back to the limelight , show up how crucial it was not just for the character ’s account , but also for Jason himself . Because Jason was Robin and , therefore , a part of Batman ’s world , it coif in motion everything that would pass to him in the future tense .
fan can check outBatman & Robin : Year Oneby Mark Waid and Chris Samnee to explore the origin of the dynamic duo of Dick Grayson and Bruce Wayne .
Jason Todd’s ‘Year One’: Tragic Foreshadowing for the Red Hood
Rewriting Robin’s Past to Set the Stage for His Inevitable Future
to boot , a ‘ Year One ’ for Jason Todd could add something new to the part : tragic foreshadowing . Jason Todd ’s original tale as Robin were n’t written with the foresight that he would be murdered by the Jokeror that he would become the Red Hood . The aspects ofJason ’s character that are now seen as foundationalto his forward-looking delineation as an anti - Hero of Alexandria were n’t even study as possibilities when he was Robin , simply because those level were n’t spell with the intent that Jason ’s future tense would demand his expiry .
By retell Jason ’s Robin stories from a modern crystalline lens and experience precisely how his time as Batman ’s crony will total to an end , DC can use Jason ’s past to build up up and lead into his futurity . The readers may fuck how Jason ’s origin will finish , but the character do n’t . No matter how badly these theatrical role in the present wish thing turned out differently , and no matter how much readers could wish well for Jason ’s future to turn out differently , there ’s nothing they can do because his destiny as Red Hood is seal .
DC is likely teasing the resurgence of Red Hood ’s retaliation - fueled daddy issues with Batman — and this time , they ’re virulent than ever .
Jason Todd is in dreadful pauperization of a ‘ Year One ’ reboot from DC Comics . His past as Robin is notably inconsistent in how he ’s picture , resulting in two issue on Jason that feel incompatible . A newfangled take on his days as Robin could synthesize his enactment while also adding a new layer of presage due to his fate already being known . As DC Comics keep to revisit the pasts of their most iconic heroes , hopefully , it ’ll breathe raw life intoRed Hood ’s .
