J.J. Abrams’ Star Trek Movie Enterprise Did What A Controversial DS9 Team Failed To Do

Star Trek

The young gang of the Starship Enterprise in J.J. Abrams’Star Trek(2009 ) achieved a desperate feat that a different group of Starfleet Academy cadet inStar Trek : Deep Space Ninefailed to do . Star Trek(2009 ) reboot Captain James T. Kirk ( Chris Pine ) , Spock ( Zachary Quinto ) , and thecast ofStar Trek : The Original Seriesas their youthful incarnations in the alternate Kelvin Timeline . Assembling as a group of cadets at Starfleet Academy , Kirk and his fellow cadets are hollo upon to command the USS Enterprise against theRomulan time traveller Nero(Eric Bana ) .

Starfleet Academy often take center degree inStar Trek ’s Prime Timelineduring the 1990sStar Trek : The Next Generation24th century era . TNGintroduced Nova Squadron , a group ofelite Starfleet Academy cadetswho covered up the death of their classmate . Star Trek : Deep Space Ninedebuted a dissimilar crop of elite plebe called Red Squad . One incarnation of Red Squad participated in an attempted coup to place Earth under Starfleet military rule . InStar Trek : Deep Space Nineseason 6 , episode 22 , " Valiant,“another Red Squad course of instruction went behind enemy agate line during the Dominion War .

Star Trek 2009’s Enterprise Crew Did What DS9’s Red Squad Failed To Do

The Enterprise’s Starfleet Academy Cadets Did Good

One of the novelty ofStar Trek(2009 ) is that James T. Kirk and most of the work party of the USS Enterprise are Starfleet Academy cadets , with Spock holding the rank and file of Commander . When Captain Christopher Pike ( Bruce Greenwood ) is captured by Nero , the Enterprise crew receives field promotions , and Kirk rockets up the rank and file to becomeCaptain of the go-ahead . Yetdespite their rawness , Kirk ’s desperate instinct and the elect skillset of the Enterprise crew examine to be enough to defeat Nero . The cadets are reward by being fully instated by Starfleet to for good overtop the Starship Enterprise .

J.J. Abrams ' Star Trek 2009 see the immature Kirk and Spock connect force to save Earth . A deep prima donna into how Star Trek 2009 terminate and what it all means .

Star Trek : Deep Space Nine ’s Red Squad(created a decade beforeStar Trek(2009 ) pip motion-picture show theaters ) undertake to make a name for themselves in a similar fashion , but failed . When Captain Ramirez is shoot down , Red Squad assume bidding of the USS Valiant to fulfill their foreign mission without Starfleet ’s authorization . Captain Tim Watters ( Paul Popowich ) occupy Red Squad ’s status as elect cadets too far in their attempt to prove they have the right stuff . In the ending , Watters led Red Squad to a tragical end with almost all hands lose .

Why Kirk’s Enterprise Succeeded When Star Trek: DS9’s Red Squad Failed

Red Squad Was A Cautionary Tale

Something James T. Kirk inStar Trek(2009 ) andRed Squad inStar Trek : Deep Space Ninehad in plebeian isa grade of hauteur and sentence that they ’re doing the right thing . However , their outcomes were wildly different . finally , Kirk and the Starship Enterprise bunch were trying to salvage Earth from the wipeout Nero bring down on Vulcan . Kirk and Spock , in exceptional , had to ascertain to trust each other and invoke the same feeling in their crew for the Starship Enterprise to work out together and emerge winning .

Red Squad was instill with a mistaken impression that they could do no wrong .

Red Squad had more of a nebulous motivating to shew why they were elect cadets . lack a defined goal ( i.e save Earth ) , Captain Watters was drive by hubris , and Red Squad was instil with a mistaken impression that they could do no wrong . Red Squad was given particular treatment at Starfleet Academy , and it breed a elusive self-importance . Captain Kirk and the Starship Enterprise were in over their heads inStar Trek(2009 ) but testify they were the skilful of Starfleet , while Red Squad showed they were the opposite inStar Trek : Deep Space Nine .