Moana
Disney has won a lawsuit file away against the successful dangerous undertaking movieMoanawhich claim the story was stolen . Released in 2016 , and directed by John Musker and Ron Clements - from a screenplay by Jared Bush - Moana tells the level of the strong - willed daughter of an island chief , chosen by the ocean to reunite the goddess Te Fiti with a mystic relic . Moana ’s castincluded newcomer Auli’i Cravalho , alongside Dwayne Johnson , Temuera Morrison , Jermaine Clement , and Alan Tudyk . The picture show was a box office succeeder , grossing $ 687.2 million worldwide , and spawn a continuation , Moana 2 .
Per report inAP News , Disney has won a case that was register against the company , claiming that the story forMoanawas stolen from a playscript calledBucky the Surfer Boy , by writer and vitaliser Buck Woodall . A jury determined that Disney had no access to Woodall ’s script or ideas , after claims he ’d given it to a remote relative who operate for a dissimilar company on the Disney lot . She claim not to have shown it to anyone from Disney and the lawsuit was overturned . Woodall has also file a suit againstMoana 2 , which will be settle separately .
What This Means For Moana 2 & Future Disney Lawsuits
The Sequel Lawsuit Is Unlikely To Be Successful Due To The Finite Nature Of Stories & Ideas
Moana 2 ’s successis unlikely to yield a positive result in the lawsuit for Woodall , andthe likelihood is that if the initial lawsuit was overturned , this one will be too . This is not the first example of a movie studio being litigate for supposed piracy , and it ’s unlikely to be the last . However , it pose an interesting public debate about the nature of right of first publication , and how musical theme give nascence to taradiddle . It could be argued that there are only a finite number of stories ever told , and everything else is a variation on those stories , meaning some will overlap thematically .
Even if the caller was shamed of slip estimate , it feel very unbelievable that they would lose a legal battle , yield the resources and finances at their administration .
Moreover , the nature of storytelling , particularly in the movie manufacture , is quite formulaic , and there are particular tarradiddle beats that need to be impinge on , so it brook to reason that there will be similarities between ideas . It is also deserving note thatmany idea share similarities in a broad sense , but often their carrying out is far enough removed that it ’s clear they are not unmediated copies . People who work in originative industries are often inspired by what has come before , and there are similarities that can by nature pass with whole kit and boodle like this .
Our Verdict On Disney’s Lawsuit Victory
It’s Hard To Imagine The Entertainment Giants Losing A Copyright Lawsuit
While the nature of copyright is a complicated one , and it is hard to prove definitively that an idea has been stolen , another factor to see here is the power Disney exert . Even if the company was shamefaced of stealing ideas , it feels very unlikely that they would turn a loss a legal battle , give way the resources and monetary resource at their disposal . Though Woodall is probable to be abortive with both hisMoanaandMoana 2lawsuits , the fact that aMoanalive - action remakewill be released soon intend this may not be the end of this particular legal chapter .
Source : AP News
Your Rating
Your comment has not been saved
Cast
Moana is a 2016 animated pic from Walt Disney Animation Studios . define in Ancient Polynesia , the story follows the journeying of a young Chieftain ’s daughter named Moana as she seek the demigod Maui to lift a curse affecting her island , explore themes of risky venture and ego - discovery .
Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Moana is a 2016 animated film from Walt Disney Animation Studios. Set in Ancient Polynesia, the story follows the journey of a young Chieftain’s daughter named Moana as she seeks the demigod Maui to lift a curse affecting her island, exploring themes of adventure and self-discovery.
