Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
I have a confession to make : as a minor , I hatedWilly Wonka and the Chocolate Factorywith Gene Wilder . It fright the heck out of me , and no matter how much I like the Sung dynasty , they did n’t overturn the incubus of a girl turning into gargantuan blueberries or hellish gravy boat ride with a screaming maniac . But when I was a trivial older , I read Roald Dahl’sCharlie and the Chocolate Factory , and get it on it . So , I resolve it was clock time to confront my fears and rewatch the 1971 musical , and I cheerily found a new appreciation for the movie .
I am also a big Tim Burton buff , and have lie with his picture show for years . When the 2005 reading ofCharlie and the Chocolate Factorypromised to be more accurate to the book , I was scheme . However , when the end credits roll , I was n’t horrified , nor overjoy by what I had just seen . rather , I was left with a flavor of cold indifference . While Burton ’s version of the Dahl classic was more accurate to the account book in some ways , it seemed to have lose much of the feeling . And one of the biggest addition thatCharlie and the Chocolate Factorymade felt altogether coerce and unwarranted .
Willy Wonka’s Backstory Was Unnecessary
Wonka Works Better As An Oddball Enigma
Director Tim Burton is illustrious for repetition coaction with actors , include the late , expectant Christopher Lee , who act Dr. Wilbur Wonka inCharlie and the Chocolate Factory . Dr. Wilbur is a tooth doctor who forbade his son Willy from exhaust hot chocolate because of the legal injury it causes to teeth . Naturally , Willy falls in love with the confectionary marvel the first moment he sneaks a bite . He then rebels and leaves home to start up his burnt umber factory , against dear papa ’s wishes . The rift cause between father and son go for decade , until the goal of the film when they are reunited and resolve their long conflict .
At no breaker point did I ever wonder who Willy Wonka was before the manufacturing plant , nor did I care to get it on .
When I saw the 2005 version for the first time , I remember wanting to shake off my popcorn at the screen for this totally unneeded bit of context . While I ca n’t speak for other lover , at no point did I ever wonder who Willy Wonka was before the factory , nor did I care to love . Not to note that the dread servant headgear that Willy was force to wear as a kidskin gave me nightmares , and really belong in aSawmovie or else of a picture show for children .
Willy Wonka ’s Golden Tickets contest might have not been as honest and unproblematic as it seems , and Charlie might have been choose to ascertain one .
In a 2005 audience withEntertainment Weekly , Burton stated that he want to explain Wonka ’s personality by search his human relationship with his beginner : “ You need a little spot of the flavor of why Wonka is the direction he is . Otherwise , what is he ? He ’s just a eldritch guy . ” I opine many buff of the book and the 1971 picture show will agree that Wonka being a “ unearthly guy wire ” without any explanation is part of what makes him so great . We love the enigma of the whimsical , oddball character , and do n’t need or want to recognise the reason behind his personality .
Reportedly , that ’s not the only reasonableness Burton add this surplus bit of traditional knowledge . In aRedditpost from 2021 , a sports fan claimedthat the theater director ’s own life experience mirror that of Willy and Wilbur ’s in the 2005 film . In 2002 , Burton , who was estranged from his mother , went to jaw her in 2002 just before she die . He was moved to find that she had hung up framed card of his picture show on the wall , just as Wilbur Wonka had display the news snip of his Logos in the film .
Custom Image by Ana Nieves
In the audio commentary forCharlie and the Chocolate Factory , Burton said,“I recollect all aesthetic endeavors are a fashion to adjudicate things , a form of therapy , a fancy of resolve something . That ’s why I chose to resolve it that way . ” ( viaWhat Culture)While I ca n’t fault him for trying to chance an outlet to fix the issues in his personal life , I just bid he had n’t used a beloved children ’s character to do it .
Gene Wilder’s Wonka Is A Better Representation Than Johnny Depp
Wilder Was Truly “Alight Of Fun And Laughter”
Tim Burton and Roald Dahl made it clean that they were not fans of the 1971 flick melodious , yet ironically , it has held up as the most favoredadaptation of Dahl ’s novel . Much of that is due to the performance of Gene Wilder , who donned the majestic suit and top hat inWilly Wonka and the Chocolate Factory . During the cast process for the ‘ 71 pic , Wilder nailed the audition and was cast straightaway ( viaLegacy).He understood the spirit of Willy Wonka from the start , even insisting upon the devious entrance where he walk with a cane before somersaulting on the carpet .
Wilder ’s characterization of Wonka was whimsical , heartfelt , and yes , perhaps even a small creepy . Yet all of this contributed to the heart of the chocolatier ’s magical spell .
The Koran identify Willy Wonka as being “ alight of fun and laugh , ” a trait that Wilder had in spade . Butthe role player also enhanced the part with his own brand name of oddball eccentricities , and was n’t afraid to lean into the darker edge of the character . Wilder ’s portrayal of Wonka was whimsical , dear , and yes , possibly even a little creepy . Yet all of this contributed to the nerve of the chocolatier ’s charm , making his eccentricity delightful and magnetic .
Johnny Depp ’s edition of Wonka , on the other script , just made fans cringe . His weirdness felt predatory and awkward , with none of the paternal expression of Wilder ’s execution . Depp once say that he establish the character on kids ' TV show hosts like Bob Keeshan ofCaptain Kangarooand Fred Rogers ofMr . Rogers ’ Neighborhood , which I detect hard to believe , because he managed to capture none of their lovingness .
The 2023 Wonka Movie Is A Much Better Backstory
It Captures The Spirit Of The Beloved 1971 Film
Where Tim Burton’sCharlie and the Chocolate Factorywas a far departure from the classic ‘ 71 film , the 2023 Warner Bros. movieWonkabrought back the magic and whimsy the franchise painfully needed . Starring Timothée Chalamet as a young Willy Wonka , the film limit up a far superior origin story for the beloved grapheme than the one from Burton ’s 2005 version .
The prequel to Roald Dahl ’s Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is filled with iconic player and comedians who institute its classical characters to lifespan .
Asa verbatim prequel toWIlly Wonka and the Chocolate Factory , Wonkastayed true to the original film , while pay homage to the spirit of Dahl ’s ledger . Chalamet ’s costume is closely plan like the one Wilder wore , and he captured the warmth and way-out mastermind of the character — albeit with a act more naivete . Like the 1971 movie , Wonkafeatures new original songs , and Chalamet sings his own rendering of the classic strain , " Pure Imagination . "
I ’ll admit that I watched the movie with some skepticism when it was released , yet I found myself rather enjoyingWonka . It takes its inspiration directly from the 1971 moving picture , rather than any of the Christian Bible , but for what it is , it ’s quite salutary . And if filmmakers importune on fall in Wonka a backstory , then this movie at least did a way better job than 2005’sCharlie and the Chocolate Factory .
Summary
The " Charlie and the Chocolate Factory " franchise is based on Roald Dahl ’s 1964 novel , sport the adventures of young Charlie Bucket in the whimsical and charming populace of Willy Wonka ’s chocolate factory . The serial publication explores themes of imagination , morality , and the import of covetousness . The dealership has been conform into films , stage musical comedy , and other media . The 2023 film " Wonka " cut into into the backstory of Willy Wonka , offering sports fan a glimpse into his early life and rise as a chocolatier .
