WithThe Boys ' fourth time of year generate the go - ahead , the continued spotlight put on Homelander shows that the " evil Superman " trope is n’t break down away anytime soon . But whileSupermanis often misjudge as being a boring , overtake boy scout , a cursory coup d’oeil at his account shows they are n’t all sunshine and rainbows .

Sometimes when writers seek to write dark Superman story , they feel attempt - hard , with level like " For Tomorrow " and the bulk of New 52 Superman stories sacrificing Superman ’s character in favor of saturated disquietude . However , the adept sour Superman stories are the ones that try his positivity in negatively charged scenarios .

Superman: Earth One

J. Michael Straczynski , Shane Davis , and Adrian Syaf ’s trilogy ofSuperman : Earth Onegraphic novels do admittedly alter Superman to make him a dark character , but there is a decent understanding for this . Earth Onepresents a Clark Kent in his former days , incertain of what he want to do with his lifespan like so many people test to hit out on their own .

The world this Superman exists in feels more natural , the scoundrel finger more threatening , and the epic superpowered battles have literal - world consequences . Though he struggles at first , by the end of the third volume , Clark begins to resemble the Man of Steel fans cognize and be intimate .

American Alien

Much likeEarth One , Superman : American Alienis a darker take on Superman ’s earlier days , give a far less dressed take on The Man of Tomorrow . key out as a " Clark Kent story,“American Alienfocuses less on the mad powers of Superman and more on the humanity of Clark Kent , the keyword of which being " human , " as the serial shows Clark Kent shinny throughout his life with his divine gifts , produce a whole load of mistakes in the process .

Though the author is n’t a very popular individual right on now , his oeuvre onAmerican Alienis lurch perfect , with each issue featuring a raw artist that adds to the story narrate . While Warner Bros and DC battle to make Superman " relatable , " this individual miniseries does it flawlessly .

What’s So Funny About Truth, Justice, And The American Way

Written by Joe Kelly , with art by Doug Mahnke and Lee Bermejo , Superman#775 , or " What ’s So Funny About Truth , Justice , and The American Way , " is one ofthe best Superman issues of the 2000s . When a more ruthless team of " submarine " call The Elite begin a campaign of callously slaughtering criminals , people start to question whether or not Superman is even take anymore .

Funeral For A Friend

" The Death of Superman " is a dark moment in Superman ’s history , but its prompt follow - up " Funeral for a Friend " is n’t just one of the darkest Superman account , it’sone of the pitiful Superman storiesof all metre . narrate in all four Superman - related title , " Funeral for a Friend " shows how the multitude in Superman ’s animation are affected by his death at the hands of Doomsday .

Moments like Martha Kent being glued to the telly watching the funeral and a weeping Lois Lane squall The Kents to rationalise for not call them sooner because she did n’t want to accept it was real are heartbreaking . However , the darkest , most heartwrenching scene is when Superman ’s biggest devotee Bibbo Bobowski cry out to God need to know why Superman died and not him .

Superman Reborn

When DC Rebirth came along , not only did the Superman fans wanted bump himself replacing the revile New 52 incarnation , but he and Lois Lane were now parents . This is what makes the " Superman : Reborn " storyline so intense , as it ’s this mob moral force that is put in peril , as when their boy Jonathan is kidnaped by a different edition of Clark Kent , a dingy secret of the post - New 52 DC Universe is laid nude .

The story run from personal to cosmic swiftly and turns a baddie that many saw as a bit camp into a true terror . The fact that " Superman : Reborn " was written by four different writer and drawn by ten dissimilar creative person does n’t palpate jarring whatsoever , as each handle the story well and the story ’s morose tint and ever - rising tension remain consistent .

Up In The Sky

Tom King and Andy Kubert gave fans one of the darkest and tensest Superman stories in late store … in a Walmart - undivided comic!Superman : Up In The Skysees Superman locomote fromhis iconic metropolis home of Metropolisto the farthest range of space all to preserve a trivial young woman .

That may not seem all that dark , but Superman ’s journey inUp In The Skyputs him through the wringer , wearing him down both physically and mentally until he is forced by Darkseid to make a vital decision that will compromise his reference regardless of his option . King and Kubert present a Superman labour to his limit , but nonetheless so dedicated to doing the right thing he is unforced to do some questionable things .

Kingdom Come

RankingKingdom Comeamong dark Superman stories feel a bit off , as it ’s technically a dark DC story , but without Superman as its chief centering the write up would n’t bring . Setin a dark future timeline , the heroes of the DC Universe return key after years of retreat to thwart a Modern generation of reckless hero and dangerous scoundrel , however , their more autocratic approach set the fate of the world in the balance .

Writer Mark Waid and artist Alex Ross craft a story dealing with root word of the corruption of icons , 90 excessiveness , religion , and Bob Hope . Seeing a Superman who has lose Leslie Townes Hope is truly disturbing , as such a want of Bob Hope distort his view on what he does .

Brainiac

Writer Geoff Johns has pen some pretty cheerful Superman stories , but his most famous Superman - centric narration is n’t among them . assure in the Thomas Nelson Page ofAction Comics , " Brainiac " watch Johns reinvent Greco-Roman Silver Age conception for the twenty-first Century such as Supergirl , the bottle urban center of Kandor , and of track , the villain know as Brainiac .

What wee-wee the history so grim is more than just the execution of Johns ' plot , but Gary Frank ’s beautiful , albeit spookily realistic graphics which presents the rubbery violence and heartrending catastrophe of " Brainiac " in almost uncomfortable particular . Not to mention , the level end on a distressing note with a intestine - lick of an ending that wo n’t be spoiled but will jerk at the heartstrings .

For The Man Who Has Everything

Alan Moore ’s Superman news report are like a distorted Cadbury Crème Egg , on the outside is a zany comic book presentation but on the interior is something much darker , " For The Man Who Has Everything " is no exception . suck by Dave Gibbons , the history sees Mongul ensnare Superman in The Black Mercy , an alien plant life that feeds off its dupe whilst trap them in their fantasy .

From the very first glimpse of Superman ’s Krypton - gear up fantasy , the reader experience that it ’s destine , which makes the instant where Superman has to excuse to his Word that he is n’t genuine all the rougher . Even after Superman is free and Mongul is kill , a wistful air is pervasive throughout the residuum of the chronicle .

Whatever Happened To The Man Of Tomorrow

WithCrisis of Infinite Earthsprimed to do by with the old persistence , it was up to Alan Moore and iconic Superman artist Curt Swan to play the Pre - Crisis Man of Steel out . " Whatever Happened To The Man of Tomorrow " showcases the final days of this Superman , with Swan ’s trend curiously complimenting Moore ’s grim storytelling .

These last Clarence Day are filled with coloured case , with many of Superman ’s allies and enemies being kill off , which lead to The Man of Steel hanging up the cape forever and a day . However , like many dark Superman stories , " Whatever Happened To The Man of Tomorrow " gives The Last Son of Krypton a happy conclusion .

NEXT:10 Best ' Clark Kent Is Superman ' Reveals In DC Comics

Jon Kent (AKA Superman’s Young Adult Son) with Kryptonite in the background

How Goku can beat Superman, explained.

James Gunn’s Superman and Krypto comic

10 Darkest Superman Comic Stories

Superman- Earth One

An image of Superman with a finger on his lips in American Alien

What’s So Funny About Truth, Justice, & The American Way

Funeral For A Friend

Comic book art: New 52 and Rebirth versions of Superman fly forward.

Comic book art: Darkseid holds up a beaten Superman in Superman: Up In The Sky.

Superman glares down at the world in Kingdom Come comics.

Superman comes face to face with Brainiac in DC Comics

Comic book art: Mongul looms over Superman

Whatever Happened To The Man of Tomorrow

Superman